Skylar was taken to a remote area and repeatedly stabbed to death. Her body was then dumped and covered it with dirt. Her dad Dave Neese raised the alarm when he went to wake her up the following day and realised her bed had not been slept in.
The girls helped with the search for Skylar and even called her parents regularly to receive updates from the police investigation. Eddy, who had been friends with Skylar since she was a young girl, also posted a tribute on Twitter in which she said "you'll ALWAYS be my best friend".
Their motive? As mentioned earlier, Skylar when alive had maintained a close relationship with Eddy from childhood,. Their friendship became strained when they met Shoaf while at high school. She reportedly became upset to see Eddy and Shoaf become close and allegedly witnessed them have lesbian sex at a sleepover. Fearing that their secret would be leaked, they decided to kill Skylar.
Six months later, Shoaf decided to confess to the crime and led the police to the dead body. She pleaded guilty to second-degree murder and was sentenced to up to 30 years in prison while Eddy admitted first-degree murder and is serving a 15-year term.